Flexibility and accuracy are critical in the field of test and measurement. Two prominent modular instrumentation platforms, PXI (PCI eXtensions for Instrumentation) and PXIe (PXI Express), were designed to be precise and effective tools that can perform a wide range of complex testing and measurement tasks with high reliability and efficiency.
While there are certain commonalities between them, there are also important distinctions that could have a big influence on your testing configuration. Let’s take a look at the features, structure, and function of each.
1. Bus Architecture
PXI: PXI is designed with the traditional PCI (Peripheral Component Interconnect) bus architecture, which means that data transfer within the PXI system occurs using the PCI bus.
PXIe: PXIe is reliant on the high-speed PCIe (Peripheral Component Interconnect Express) bus architecture. This device features more rapid data transfer rates compared to the older version of the PCI bus, which enhances overall performance.
2. Data Transfer Rates
PXI: PXI provides a maximum data transfer rate of about 132 MB/s per slot via the PCI bus. While this works well for many applications, it might not be sufficient for high-bandwidth activities.
PXIe: In this area, PXIe excels because it provides noticeably faster data transfer rates. It uses PCIe Gen 3.0 to deliver up to 8 GB/s per slot. Because of this, it is the best option for applications that require a lot of data capacity.
3. Backward Compatibility
PXI: PXI modules and PXIe slots typically cannot coexist due to variations in bus architectures. To provide some degree of backward compatibility, certain PXI chassis, however, have hybrid slots that accommodate both PXI and PXIe modules.
PXIe: PXIe chassis are often designed with hybrid slots that can accept both PXIe and PXI modules, offering more flexibility in module selection.
4. Module Size
PXI: PXI modules are typically larger in size than PXIe modules. This can be an important consideration if space within the chassis is limited.
5. Cost
PXI: Generally speaking, PXI modules and chassis are less expensive than their PXIe equivalents. Because of this, PXI can be a better choice for applications where fast data transfer speeds are not critical.
6. Application Suitability
PXI: PXI is well-suited for a broad range of test and measurement applications. It’s an excellent choice when high data bandwidth is not critical or when budget constraints are a concern.
PXIe: High-bandwidth and high-speed applications are where PXIe excels. For demanding applications requiring high data throughput, such as digital communication testing and RF and microwave testing, this platform is the preferred choice.
When to Choose PXI
> Budget Constraints: If your project has a limited budget and you do not need very high data transfer rates, PXI can be a more cost-effective solution. Many test and measurement tasks can still be accomplished with PXI, especially if your application doesn’t require a lot of data capacity.
> General–Purpose Testing: When high-speed data transport is not the primary focus, PXI is suitable for general-purpose testing and measuring applications. This covers jobs like testing sensors, measuring voltage and frequency, and performing simple signal analysis.
> Legacy Systems: If you have an existing PXI setup or older PXI modules, it may be best to stick with this model in order to maintain compatibility and avoid unnecessary expenses. You can consider gradually upgrading to PXIe over time.
Find the legacy test equipment you need at Test Equipment Surplus! We are a leading supplier of new and reconditioned, obsolete and discontinued test equipment. Browse our Test Equipment Surplus to find your product or contact us to receive a quote!
> Space Constraints: When it comes to situations when you have limited space in your testing setup, PXI’s larger module size could be easier to handle than PXIe modules’ larger form factor.
When to Choose PXIe:
> High-Bandwidth Applications: Applications requiring considerable bandwidth and fast data transfer perform exceptionally well with PXIe. This covers jobs like high-frequency signal analysis, sophisticated communication protocols, and RF and microwave testing.
> Future-Proofing: If you anticipate that your testing requirements will include high-bandwidth tasks, PXIe is the best option. This is because its PCIe-based architecture offers room for scalability and future expansion.
> Backward Compatibility Needs: Selecting a PXIe chassis with hybrid slots can provide the ability to support different module types if you have a combination of PXI and PXIe modules or expect to require compatibility with both.
> Industry Standards: When choosing between PXI and PXIe, it’s important to consider industry-specific standards and requirements. Certain industries, such as aerospace and telecommunications, may have standards that suggest or require PXIe for various testing methods.
> Signal Integrity: For applications where signal integrity is critical, such as high-speed digital testing or ultra-low noise measurements, PXIe’s improved data transfer rates and performance may be essential.
> Collaborative Projects: If you plan to collaborate or work with other organizations who primarily use PXIe, choosing PXIe can simplify data interchange and compatibility.
Hybrid Connectors: PXI and PXIe Compatibility
Hybrid connectors serve as a bridge between the two standards and are necessary for the seamless integration of PXI modules with PXIe chassis. When PXI modules with hybrid connectors are used in PXIe chassis, test systems become more versatile and adaptable. This compatibility will be especially helpful to organizations that have a mix of older PXI modules and more modern PXIe systems, as it lets them maximize their present investments without having to start from scratch when it comes to testing infrastructure. Customers can benefit from PXIe’s extra features without compromising the operation of their PXI modules thanks to the hybrid slot on a PXIe chassis, which is designed to accommodate both PXI and PXIe modules.
In addition, the use of hybrid connectors in PXI modules allows customers to switch from PXI to PXIe systems with efficiency. This is especially important for applications that demand high data transmission rates and improved PXIe synchronization capabilities but still rely on PXI modules that are currently in use. If hybrid connectivity is allowed, users can gradually enhance their systems by using current, reliable PXI modules while also adding new PXIe modules to boost performance.
This approach, which maximizes the cost and efficiency of the test systems while also extending the equipment’s lifespan, makes hybrid connections a crucial component of modern automated test and measurement setups.
Choosing between PXI and PXIe will essentially depend on your specific test and measurement requirements. Consider your needs and select the platform that best aligns with your objectives.